Tag Archives: Canada

How many sexual assaults each year?

A round table topic on The Sara Mills Show yesterday was the under-reporting of sexual assaults.  One of the guests said that only 3 of every 1000 sexual assaults resulted in a conviction.  That number seemed really low so I asked about it.  The source is an infographic produced by the YWCA and highlighted in a Huffington Post article.

o-SEXUAL-ASSAULT-CANADA-570

Where did that 460,000 number come from?  How do you count sexual assaults that aren’t reported?

The source cited is the chapter “Limits of a Criminal Justice Response: Trends in Police and Court Processing of Sexual Assault” by Holly Johnson in the book Sexual Assault in Canada: Law, Legal Practice and Women’s Activism, edited by Elizabeth Sheehy and published in 2012.

Where did she get the number?

Her source was the 2004 General Social Survey (Victimization)conducted by Statistics Canada.  A summary is available.  The question asked was “During the past 12 months, has anyone ever touched you against your will in any sexual way?  By this I mean anything from unwanted touching or grabbing, to kissing or fondling.”

So, 460,000 is an estimate of “sexual assault” calculated based on a survey of ~24,000 people and includes unwanted touching, grabbing, kissing, or fondling.  Is it any wonder that these “assaults” are not reported?

The truth is that we don’t know how many sexual assaults go unreported because they are not reported.  Based on the overly broad definition used above, it’s safe to say that the number is much less than 460,000 per year.  Exaggerating doesn’t strengthen your point; it weakens your position because your audience won’t trust your other “facts”.

 

 

6412 murdered women*

A headline in yesterday’s StarPhoenix stated that “1,026 aboriginal women killed merits inquiry”.

Don’t all murders merit inquiry?  According to Stats Canada counts of homicide victims, in 2011 there were 598 homicides — 422 men, 276 women.  Based on the RCMP report cited in the StarPhoenix article by Stephen Maher, 16% of murdered women are aboriginal.  Therefore, we can extrapolate that 44 aboriginal women and 232 non-aboriginal women were murdered in 2011.  Why does one group merit a special inquiry?

It is possible that many of the murdered women share characteristics which might provide clues about where to focus prevention strategies.  Examining only aboriginal victims assumes that race is the primary factor and limits the power to identify other risk factors.  For that matter, this discussion also ignores the far greater number of murdered men.

*If 1026 murdered aboriginal women represent 16% of all women murdered, the total number of women murdered over 30 years equals 6412.